Yes, Square accepts American Express, but the processing fee is higher than for Visa or Mastercard

Square processes American Express payments through its standard payment terminal and online checkout. When a customer pays with an Amex card, the transaction goes through like any other card payment. However, Square charges a different rate for Amex transactions than it does for Visa or Mastercard — typically 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction for in-person payments, compared to 2.6% plus $0.30 for Visa and Mastercard. The exact Amex rate depends on your Square account type and sales volume.

This rate difference exists because American Express sets its own interchange fees, which are the costs Square pays to process the transaction. Those costs get passed to you as the merchant. Unlike Visa and Mastercard, which are card networks that banks issue cards through, American Express is both the network and the card issuer — they set their own pricing structure.

Key Takeaways

  • Square accepts Amex cards at all payment terminals and through online checkout without any special setup required.
  • American Express transactions cost you more per transaction than Visa or Mastercard because Amex sets higher interchange fees.
  • You cannot opt out of accepting Amex while using Square — it comes as part of the standard payment processing agreement.
  • The rate difference means a $100 Amex purchase costs you $3.30 in fees, while the same amount on Visa or Mastercard costs $2.90.

How the fee structure works

Square's pricing for Amex is tiered based on how you accept the payment. In-person card-present transactions (when the customer physically taps or inserts their card) are charged at one rate. Card-not-present transactions — online payments, phone orders, or mail orders — are charged at a higher rate because the fraud risk is greater. Amex card-not-present transactions typically run 3.5% plus $0.15 per transaction on most Square accounts.

The fee is calculated on the full transaction amount, including tax. If a customer buys $50 in goods and $5 in tax, you pay the percentage on $55. This applies to all card types, but because Amex's percentage is higher, the total cost is higher even on the same dollar amount.

Whether you can refuse American Express

You cannot selectively decline Amex while accepting other cards through Square. When you sign up for Square payment processing, you agree to accept all major card types, including American Express. This is a condition of the merchant agreement, not a choice you can change in your settings.

If you want to refuse Amex payments, you would need to stop using Square entirely and switch to a different payment processor — and even then, most major processors require you to accept all four major card networks (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover). Some very small or specialized processors may allow selective acceptance, but this is rare and often comes with higher fees on the cards you do accept.

Why Amex costs more

American Express cardholders tend to have higher average transaction values and lower default rates than Visa or Mastercard customers. This means Amex customers are statistically lower risk. However, Amex charges higher interchange fees anyway because they operate differently from Visa and Mastercard. Amex is a closed-loop system — they issue the card, own the network, and set all the fees. Visa and Mastercard are open networks where banks issue the cards and the networks handle routing.

Amex's higher fees also reflect the benefits they market to cardholders: higher rewards rates, premium customer service, and purchase protections. Those benefits cost money, and that cost is built into the interchange fee that merchants pay. When you accept an Amex card, you are partly funding the rewards that Amex customer received for using that card.

What happens if a customer wants to pay with Amex

When a customer taps or inserts an American Express card into a Square reader, the transaction processes automatically. The customer sees the same receipt and approval message as they would with any other card. From the customer's perspective, there is no difference — the higher fee is invisible to them and comes out of your revenue, not theirs.

If you are concerned about the fee, you cannot prevent the customer from using Amex, but you can inform customers of your payment methods before they reach checkout. Some businesses display signage showing which cards they accept, though this is uncommon in the US because most merchants accept all major cards. Refusing payment after a customer has already initiated the transaction would damage your reputation and is not a practical business strategy.

Comparing Square to other processors for Amex

Square's Amex rates are competitive with other major processors like Stripe, PayPal, and Toast. Stripe charges 2.9% plus $0.30 for Amex in-person and 3.5% plus $0.15 for card-not-present. PayPal charges similar rates. The difference between processors is usually small — a few tenths of a percent — and often depends on your sales volume and account type rather than the processor itself.

If Amex fees are a significant concern for your business, the better strategy is to negotiate volume discounts with your processor or to encourage customers to use lower-cost payment methods like debit cards or ACH transfers. Some businesses offer a small discount for cash or debit payments, though this must be disclosed clearly and cannot be framed as a surcharge on credit cards in most states.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I see which transactions were Amex before I'm charged?

Yes. Square's dashboard breaks down transactions by card type in your settlement report. You can see how many Amex transactions you processed and the total fees charged. This information is available in real time, so you can track Amex volume throughout the day or week.

What if an Amex transaction is declined?

Square will notify you immediately that the transaction was declined and why — usually insufficient funds, incorrect PIN, or the card being reported lost or stolen. You are not charged a fee for a declined transaction. The customer can try a different card or payment method.

Do I pay the Amex fee even if the customer disputes the charge?

You pay the fee when the transaction is processed, not when it settles. If the customer disputes the charge and wins a chargeback, Square reverses the payment to the customer's card and you lose the revenue. You do not get the processing fee back, but you also do not pay an additional chargeback fee on top of it in most cases.

Is there a way to pass the Amex fee to the customer?

In most US states, you can add a surcharge to credit card payments, but the surcharge cannot exceed the actual cost you pay to process that card type. You must disclose the surcharge clearly before checkout. Some states prohibit surcharges entirely, so check your state law before implementing this. Amex's cardholder agreement also restricts how you can communicate surcharges, so review their rules as well.