What judges actually look at when they set alimony

Alimony amounts are not set by a formula or a table. A judge looks at the income of both spouses, how long the marriage lasted, the standard of living during the marriage, and each person's ability to support themselves. The judge then decides whether one spouse should pay the other, and if so, how much and for how long. Different states weight these factors differently, and some states have guidelines that suggest a range, but the final number comes from a judge's decision in your case.

The calculation is not automatic. Even if your state has guidelines, a judge can order more or less than the guideline suggests if the circumstances warrant it. This is why two similar divorces in the same state can result in very different alimony orders.

Key Takeaways

  • Judges consider both spouses' income, the length of the marriage, and the standard of living during the marriage when setting alimony.
  • Some states use guidelines that suggest a percentage of the higher earner's income, but judges can deviate from these guidelines.
  • The ability of the lower-earning spouse to become self-supporting through work or education affects how much alimony is ordered.
  • Alimony is typically temporary for shorter marriages and can be permanent for long marriages, depending on state law and the judge's ruling.

Income: what counts and what does not

Income includes wages, salary, bonuses, and commissions. It also includes income from rental property, investments, business ownership, and retirement accounts. Some judges count unemployment benefits, disability payments, and workers' compensation as income for alimony purposes.

What does not count varies by state, but typically excludes child support received from another relationship, means-tested benefits like TANF or SSI, and sometimes Social Security retirement benefits. Self-employment income is counted, but the judge may adjust it downward if business expenses are high or if the business is new and unstable.

If one spouse is deliberately underemployed — working part-time when they could work full-time, or taking a lower-paying job after the divorce filing — the judge may "impute" income, meaning they calculate alimony based on what that person could earn, not what they actually earn.

Length of marriage and alimony duration

How long you were married directly affects how long alimony lasts. A marriage of two to three years typically results in temporary alimony lasting one to three years. A marriage of five to ten years might result in alimony lasting half the length of the marriage. A marriage of twenty years or more often results in permanent alimony, meaning it continues until the receiving spouse remarries or either spouse dies.

Some states have specific rules: for example, a few states say alimony should last no longer than 30 to 50 percent of the marriage length for marriages under ten years. Other states give judges broad discretion regardless of marriage length. The judge's order will specify an end date or state that alimony is permanent.

Standard of living during the marriage

The judge asks: what lifestyle did both spouses enjoy while married? If the marriage was comfortable and the higher earner's income supported that comfort, alimony is meant to help the lower earner maintain a similar standard of living after the divorce. This does not mean the lower earner gets to live exactly as before — but it means the judge considers what both people were accustomed to.

If the marriage was brief or the couple lived modestly, the standard of living factor carries less weight. If the marriage was long and the couple lived well, this factor pushes the alimony amount higher. The judge looks at housing, travel, education, entertainment, and other spending patterns during the marriage.

Age, health, and ability to work

A spouse who is sixty-five years old and in poor health will likely receive more alimony or alimony for a longer period than a spouse who is thirty-five and in good health. The judge considers whether the lower-earning spouse can realistically enter the job market, retrain for a new career, or work full-time.

If one spouse left the workforce to raise children or support the other spouse's career, the judge may order alimony to give that person time to return to work or complete education. If the lower-earning spouse has a degree and work experience but simply chose not to work, the judge may order less alimony or a shorter duration.

Disability or chronic illness that prevents work is a strong factor in favor of longer or higher alimony. A judge will consider medical evidence and expert testimony about work capacity.

Contributions to the marriage beyond money

The judge considers non-financial contributions: raising children, managing the household, supporting the other spouse's education or career advancement, and building the marital estate. If one spouse worked while the other earned a professional degree, or if one spouse stayed home while the other built a business, the judge factors this into the alimony decision.

This does not mean a homemaker automatically receives alimony, but it means the judge does not ignore years spent outside the paid workforce. The contribution is weighed against other factors like the length of the marriage and the current earning capacity of both spouses.

State guidelines and how they work

About half of U.S. states have alimony guidelines — formulas that suggest an amount based on the income difference between the spouses. A common guideline is 30 percent of the higher earner's gross income minus 20 percent of the lower earner's gross income, but this varies widely by state. Some states cap the guideline at a certain income level; others apply it to all income.

Even where guidelines exist, they are not binding. A judge can order more or less than the guideline suggests if the case circumstances justify it. The judge must state reasons for deviating from the guideline. States without guidelines give judges full discretion to set alimony based on the factors listed above.

You can find your state's guideline by searching "[your state] alimony guidelines" or by asking a family law attorney in your state. The guideline is a starting point, not a ceiling or floor.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the judge always order alimony?

No. If both spouses have similar income and earning capacity, or if the marriage was very short, the judge may order no alimony at all. The judge must find that one spouse lacks sufficient income to meet their reasonable needs and that the other spouse has the ability to pay before ordering alimony.

Can alimony be changed after the divorce is final?

Yes, if there is a substantial change in circumstances — such as a job loss, serious illness, or significant income increase — either spouse can ask the court to modify the alimony amount or duration. The change must be significant and not temporary. The judge will reconsider the factors and may raise, lower, or terminate alimony.

What happens to alimony if the receiving spouse remarries?

In most states, alimony ends automatically if the receiving spouse remarries. Some states also end alimony if the receiving spouse cohabits with a partner in a committed relationship, though this varies. The paying spouse must notify the court of the remarriage to stop payments.

Is alimony tax deductible?

As of 2019, alimony is no longer tax deductible for the paying spouse or taxable income for the receiving spouse under federal law. This changed from prior rules. State tax treatment may differ, so check with a tax professional about your state's rules.

How do judges handle self-employment income for alimony?

Judges count self-employment income but may adjust it for legitimate business expenses. If the business is new, unstable, or shows losses, the judge may use an average of several years or impute a lower income. The judge may also require documentation like tax returns and business records to verify the income claimed.